FT Has Kind Words for Ecuador's Response to Oil Prices

This article from Financial Times looks at the way Ecuador and Venezuela have responded to their loss of oil income. FT mostly praises Ecuador.

Ecuador ... where oil generates about half of exporters (sic) and a quarter of government revenues, “has reacted quickly to adjust its fiscal plans as prices have fallen” says LatAm Confidential. The price of Ecuadorean crude, which like Venezuela's trades at a discount because of its lower quality, has more than halved to some $40 from above $95 a year ago. But Correa, an economist trained in Belgium and the US, made a difficult adjustment last month, slicing his country's budget by 4 per cent to about $35bn. Ecuador secured $7.5bn from China to help maintain public spending and bridge a deficit that is still set to grow this year between $8.8bn and $10.5bn – up from last year's estimates of $5.5bn. The government also announced a tax reform that could raise some $200m a year ...


Venezuela, not so much:

Embattled Venezuela is more exposed to lower oil prices. Last year, crude accounted for 96 per cent of exports and about half of the government's revenues. As the socialist administration had already cut imports, LatAm Confidential says, “the government initially responded to the oil price falls by looking to cover declining revenues with foreign borrowing.”

But despite vague announcements of $20bn in investments and financing after a trip to China in January, it is unclear how much President Nicolás Maduro really secured from Venezuela's main lender.

The average price of Venezuelan crude last year was almost $98 a barrel; it now trades at $49. With its supply of dollars imploding, the government has once again tinkered with its Byzantine foreign exchange system, a move that for LatAm Confidential “will have limited effect”. The government has also raised some $2.8bn through its US-based refining company, Citgo, and accepted $1.9bn from the Dominican Republic to wipe out a $4bn debt for oil sales under the PetroCaribe agreement. That has, for now, warded off the spectre of debt default, which LatAm Confidential nevertheless believes is possible in the second half of the year.

President Correa deserves much credit. Must admit, personally was in the group that had thought low oil prices could/would be disastrous for Ecuador. Suppose if they remain low for several years that's still a possibility, but think that Ecuador is in a much better economic position than initially thought. Disagree with some of the views of President Correa, but at least he seems to face realities when they happen, and take action. Compared to Venezuela who still seems to think that it's the world's moral responsibility to raise oil prices to help their economy.

j600rr:

I agree.

Saying that someone is better/more realistic than Maduro is setting the bar pretty low, but I think it's fair to say that Correa is much better. And that's coming from someone who is definitely not a fan of Correa.

BobH wrote:

j600rr:

I agree.

Saying that someone is better/more realistic than Maduro is setting the bar pretty low, but I think it's fair to say that Correa is much better. And that's coming from someone who is definitely not a fan of Correa.


Suppose it would be almost impossible to be worse than Maduro, even if you tried.

If people are or aren't a fan of Correa is irrelevant. Onjectively I think there is some legitimate questions, and concerns, but you still can't take away his accomplishments. He clearly cares about Ecuador, and the Ecuadorian people, and has made vast improvements throughout the country. Has the majority of Ecuadorians standard of life improved under his administration? Again. Objectively speaking. I think without question the answer is yes.

I doubt the FT would approve of this article dated 02/28/2015  titled "Se reducen las ventas en los locales de tecnología" (Sales are down in stores of technology)

El incremento entre un cinco y 25 por ciento en los precios de artículos tecnológicos, entre ellos computadores portátiles, memorias, impresoras y suministros; afecta a los negocios cuencanos dedicados a la comercialización de estos productos


A 5 to 25 percent increase in the prices of technology including laptops, memory, printers and supplies is affecting sales at computer stores.

Marco Barros, gerente de PC Expertos, comenta que el incremento de precios se debe a las restricciones que tienen los productos de importación. “Son 152 artículos tecnológicos los que se ven afectados”, indica el comerciante


A manager of PC Expertos says the prices have gone up due to the restrictions on importations of 152 products.

Me: So already expensive technology has become more expensive and further out of reach for most Ecuadorians.

Mr. Barros makes a very legitimate argument Nards. With the strong dollar, now would be a perfect time to loosen some of the import restrictions, and fees (in my opinion). I'm not going to sit here, and pretend to be a huge Correa supporter. Still think that some of his policies could have long term negative impacts on the country, but am not going to say he's done a bad job either. Ecuador has come a long way in a few short years. Do they still have a long way to go, and do they still face many challenges headed into the future? Absolutely. Will the future be a boom, or bust for Ecuador? Have absolutely no idea.

Nards Barley wrote:

I Me: So already expensive technology has become more expensive and further out of reach for most Ecuadorians.


Seems a catch 22, Nards.  If Ecuador reduces the import restrictions then there is an issue with their balance of payments.  If technology is too expensive and new technology is out of reach...then how will the IT professionals ever hope to compete in a world where other have easy access to the newest tech? 

The world market is a pretty unforgiving place.

Mike

Not exactly on topic, but it relates to oil, which does have an impact on Ecuador. There are many variables that could play out in different ways, which would obviously have an impact on prices. However, looks like it's quite possible that any country counting on a rebound in oil, and the prices remaining high for any length of time could find themselves in trouble.

Article basically goes into a bit of detail of just how super efficient, and productive u.s. oil and gas companies have become, and how the price only needs to be in the mere $60-$70 price range for them to be profitable.

http://www.financialsense.com/contribut … -u-s-shale